Update 1230
| Live Services | A Proportional Response / Pursuit of Perfection |
|---|---|
| Editorial | God’s Mercy Endures; What About Ours? |
| Current Events | This Week in the News |
| Q&A | The Future of France |
| The Work | Preaching the Gospel and Feeding the Flock |
Live Services
A Proportional Response / Pursuit of Perfection
On this Sabbath, Frank Bruno will give the sermonette, titled, “A Proportional Response,” and Rene Messier will give the sermon, titled, “Pursuit of Perfection.”
The live services are available, over video and audio, at http://eternalgod.org/live-services/ (12:30 pm Pacific Time; 1:30 pm Mountain Time; 2:30 pm Central Time; 3:30 pm Eastern Time; 8:30 pm Greenwich Mean Time; 9:30 pm Central European Time). Just click on Connect to Live Stream.
Editorial
God’s Mercy Endures; What About Ours?
by Frank Bruno
As it is true for so many immigrant families of the 20th century, life was defined by hard work and sacrifice. My own grandparents, who emigrated from Italy to New York City, worked hard to enable their children to seek education and opportunities in life. Similarly, a few hundred miles to the north, two other Italian immigrants were raising their children. One of their sons, Francesco Caprio, known as Frank, would go on to impact the lives of many people in a positive way. Frank was born in 1936, and went on to earn a bachelor’s degree and later his law degree in Boston. With God’s blessing, the support of his parents and his own hard work, Frank became a municipal judge in Providence Rhode Island in 1985. That was not particularly noteworthy—what was significant was the type of judge Frank Caprio became.
Judge Caprio invited his dad, a grocer and fruit peddler, to his courtroom for his first day on the bench. A young mother of 3 came before him with several municipal violations. When she could not adequately explain the reason for the violations, Judge Caprio levied a harsh penalty on her. In his chambers following Court, he asked his father how he did. He anticipated that his dad was going to praise his son. After all, he had worked hard to earn his degrees and his seat as a judge. Rather than praising, he expressed his shock and disappointment with the harsh treatment that his son had shown to the young woman. Judge Caprio defended himself: “But Dad, she broke the law, was arrogant and would not try to explain herself!” His father did not hesitate in telling his son that the woman was obviously terrified at being in the courtroom with her three children, and rather than showing compassion, his son chose the harshest punishment available. His father went on to explain to his son that the woman was so afraid that she could not speak, let alone attempt to explain the reason for the violations.
Decades later, Judge Caprio shared in an interview that this moment altered him. He never again wanted to disappoint his father by being the harsh, unforgiving person his dad had seen in action. He understood, that for so many residents of his small New England city, he was perhaps the only part of the government that people would interact with. He learned to show compassion, empathy, and to try to understand what the person in front of him was dealing with in life.
Judge Caprio became well-known as a compassionate and well-loved jurist. While he still held people to account for infractions, he sought to understand them and to give them the opportunity to correct their poor choices. If a defendant had ten dollars in his or her pocket and the fine of $10 would leave them without any resources, Judge Caprio would either reduce the fine, or, if the situation warranted, he’d pay the fine from a fund established in his mother’s name. He helped young, old, veterans, and struggling students and immigrants to understand that violating the law had consequences, but that they needed to change their motivation and do better.
Consider the parable of the Lost Son in Luke 15:11-31. The son said to his father: “I have sinned against heaven and in your sight, and am no longer worthy to be called your son.” The father in this situation could have imposed a harsh punishment on his errant son, but he realized that his son had suffered and had learned that his profligate ways had been sinful against God and his father’s authority. Instead of further punishment, his father celebrated his return to the family and also to God.
Consider also God’s mercy with His disobedient people when in 586 B.C., He allowed the Babylonian army to destroy the temple and persecute His people. Still, God was compassionate, as we read in the Book of Lamentations, 3:22-24: “Through the LORD’S mercies we are not consumed, Because His compassions fail not. They are new every morning; Great is Your faithfulness. The LORD is my portion, says my soul, Therefore I hope in Him.”
If God can be merciful and allow for second and many more chances to repent, can we not find a similar compassion? God will always renew His mercy towards us if we sincerely repent. David reflected on this in Psalm 103:10-12: “He has not dealt with us according to our sins, Nor punished us according to our iniquities. For as the heavens are high above the earth, So great is His mercy toward those who fear Him; As far as the east is from the west, So far has He removed our transgressions from us.”
Judge Caprio died in 2025 and continues to be mourned by the many people whose lives he touched. For true Christians, our Father is relentless in His mercy and compassion if we correct our sinful ways. His mercy endures—what about our compassion?
Current Events
By Norbert Link
We address the ongoing “negotiations” pertaining to Russia and Ukraine which seem to go nowhere, as the American “mediators” or the Europeans are no match for Putin; point out the fact that many Europeans and Germans are crying out for a Führer and a powerful European army; and report on the incredible problems with Microsoft and the American aviation and banking systems.
Inasmuch as these events are hardly “coincidental,” we also warn of further demonic AI developments.
We point out once again that Jeffrey Epstein was murdered; that Iran has not been defeated; and that Donald Trump seems to be planning a military invasion of Cuba.
Please view our new StandingWatch program, titled, “Unexplained Outages and Unparalleled Chaos in America…”
This Week in the News
Where Is Europe’s One Voice?
The Associated Press wrote on November 12:
“European nations are seeking an envoy to represent them in talks on ending the Russia-Ukraine war… Ukraine is eager for support from its European allies, as it’s reluctant to leave the talks solely in the hands of a U.S. administration that has often seemed to lean toward Moscow’s views. Russia does not want European countries involved in direct negotiations… European leaders also distrust U.S. President Donald Trump to negotiate on their behalf after a series of tense standoffs over trade, Greenland and conflicts in Iran and Ukraine. ‘Without Europeans, there is no support for Ukraine,’ French President Emmanuel Macron said at a meeting of the European Political Community in Dublin on Thursday. ‘There is no more U.S. support.’…
“European leaders fear Russian President Vladimir Putin will press Trump to back a peace settlement that weakens not just Ukraine but broader European security. Putin has demanded NATO troops be pulled back from Russia’s borders and that no European forces be deployed in Ukraine…
“Italian Prime Minister Giorgia… Meloni… has increasingly pushed for a common EU representative for Europe to speak with ‘a single, authoritative voice’… some leaders deeply distrust the U.S.-brokered talks. Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk was critical of the negotiations, reflecting a regional pessimism among EU countries formerly dominated by the Soviet Union. ‘In my opinion, calling them negotiations is an exaggeration,’ Tusk said Thursday. ‘We will not build a new security architecture simply because the Russian president, or someone in the United States, wishes it.’”
The Guardian wrote on November 12:
“During the talks at the Kremlin with the US envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff on Thursday, the Russian president refused to soften his territorial demands, insisting on full control over four Ukrainian regions that Moscow claims to have annexed.”
No Single Voice
Zaobao wrote on November 14:
“After months of hesitation, EU leaders have agreed that five major military powers and [two] EU institutions will represent Europe at the next round of Ukraine peace talks.
“Reuters reported that European Council President Antonio Costa announced on Friday (13 November) that the team representing Europe at the next round of Russia-Ukraine talks would comprise France, Germany, Italy, Poland, the UK and [two more] EU institutions.”
Which means: Total Failure.
Russia Not on Board
Nasa Niva reported on November 17:
“Vladimir Putin’s aide Yuri Ushakov stated that the participation of European Union representatives in trilateral talks on ending the Russia-Ukraine war had not been agreed upon with Russia….
“Prior to that, Donald Trump’s representatives Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner had given assurances about an allegedly reached agreement with the Russians regarding the subsequent participation of Europeans.”
Most Europeans Want a European Army as USA Is Considered a Threat
Politico wrote on November 13:
“Some 71% of Europeans want the EU to have its own army… support for the European Union to have its own army was strong across the member countries surveyed, reaching 82% in Romania followed by Lithuania at 78% and France at 75%. Even in countries traditionally wary of European defense integration, majorities backed the idea with some 70% of respondents in Poland and Bulgaria in support of an EU army, alongside 69% in Germany…
“… more than one-third of respondents across the European countries surveyed now consider the United States a security threat. Around half of respondents in Germany, France and Britain held that view…”
With the current incompetent divided European member states, they won’t get an army. 10 nations or groups of nations will (have) to take the initial lead.
A New Führer
On November 12, Der Westen reported:
“According to a new study, nearly one in three Germans can, at least to some extent, embrace the idea of a ‘leader’ (‘Führer’) who governs the country with a strong hand. Far-right attitudes are also gaining more traction. These figures are striking. Yet, the vast majority of the population remains committed to democracy. However, trust begins to crumble when it comes to political reality—a finding highlighted by the ‘Leipzig Authoritarianism Study 2026,’ presented on Wednesday (November 11). The research team, led by Oliver Decker, points to a historic low and observes a growing longing for authoritarian leadership…
“11.3 percent of respondents either mostly or completely agree with the statement: ‘We should have a leader (‘Führer’) who governs Germany with a strong hand for the benefit of all.’ Another 18.7 percent express partial agreement. Taken together, this amounts to exactly 30 percent—though the researchers explicitly distinguish between clear and merely partial agreement… Even the notion that a dictatorship could, under certain circumstances, be a better form of government finds supporters: nearly six percent agree clearly, while another 16.8 percent agree in part…
“Furthermore, the researchers observe an increasing idealization of the past. Many people yearn for a supposedly better time, while others desire a radical break with the existing order…”
The time will come when Europe will become a full-fledged dictatorship under a mighty and powerful Führer.
Microsoft and Outlook Troubles
Daily Mail wrote on November 13:
“Microsoft has been battling to fix the widespread outage that has knocked out various platforms, including Outlook, for millions worldwide with the company acknowledging that efforts to restore services were ‘not taking as expected.’ Millions of users around the world began reporting that Outlook was down shortly after 6pm GMT on Thursday, in what experts have dubbed the ‘most disruptive email-related business outage of all time’.
“More than 17 hours later, users are still unable to open their inboxes, send emails and access other Microsoft services.”
How fragile our advanced societies really are. Note the next set of articles.
All Flights Halted Across US
Huffington Post wrote on November 13:
‘The FAA said there was a ‘temporary telecommunications outage’ and that ‘out of an abundance of caution all flights have been halted.’ Flights were halted at airports across the country on Friday afternoon, with the Federal Aviation Administration citing ‘extraordinary circumstances’ for the sudden stoppage…
“… the FAA announced this week that it was expanding the use of an $875 million artificial intelligence tool, SMART, to ‘assist in managing air traffic across the entire national airspace system,’ Ars Technica reported Thursday. Asked at a press conference whether the new AI tool had anything to do with the grounding of flights, Department of Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin admonished the reporter for not using the term ‘SI,’ for ‘super intelligence.’ ‘We call it SI around here, remember? SI.’ Mullin said…”
What an arrogant and quite frankly blasphemous response.
Archaic Equipment in a Remote Location?
The Daily Mail wrote on November 14:
“Trump’s transportation secretary has blamed archaic equipment found in a ‘remote location’ as the preliminary cause of the historic ground stop… Department of Transportation Chief Sean Duffy told reporters at a press conference at the agency’s headquarters on Saturday that a contractor, L3Harris, was replacing old technology at a ‘remote location’ when the air traffic control communications issue began.
“Duffy said that a contractor was doing maintenance at at least one of four remote Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) locations and was switching lines from old copper wire to fiber before communications stalled. He called L3Harris the department’s ‘legacy provider,’ accusing the contractor of failing to ‘meet the moment,’ causing the outage. … Duffy said the wire being replaced was so old it was being discontinued, prompting the routine maintenance. He explained that as the wire was being replaced from copper to fiber, it flooded other routers and disrupted the radar feeds, making it difficult for air traffic control to communicate.”
Lame explanation.
More Money Won’t Fix the Problem
The New York Post wrote on November 14:
“The most troubling consistency of both the press conferences on Friday and Saturday was the officials’ eagerness to blame Congress for not budgeting enough money to speed the modernization of the FAA’s communication network… Coming in the midst of the mysterious shutdown, the not-enough-money argument struck me as being predictable and off key. Washington is now $40 trillion in debt, or about $121,000 for each US resident. How much is enough?…
“Moreover, if you were stuck at an airport or were unsure about planning to fly in coming days and weeks, watching the person in charge demanding billions more of taxpayer dollars was hardly comforting or convincing. Even if Congress wrote the check tomorrow, the work would take years. So the cavalry is not coming soon. Such pleas always sound like everything would be fine if only America spent more.”
America’s entire aviation system is broken. And it affects the entire world.
Chaos Makes Some Wonder
The Associated Press wrote on November 16:
“Maybe the trouble started with the AI billionaire and the Silicon Valley chaos that followed talk of his infidelity, including with an alleged Chinese spy. Or maybe it was the Microsoft outage that, depending on how you looked at it, either cast millions of frustrated workers adrift or spared them from a daily, unrelenting electronic avalanche.
“But by Friday afternoon, when U.S. aviation authorities ordered the grounding of planes across the country, it felt to many that something was up. Something was broken…
“Throw in a few more examples just from Friday – a cruise ship that overturned in New Orleans when a tanker slammed into it, suspicious drones over a U.S. air base in Britain, a bomb found near an ethanol plant in Illinois — and perhaps things seem even weirder, opening the door for a writer who has been picking at America’s fears for generations to offer his own explanation. ‘The aliens have landed,’ Stephen King wrote in a Friday afternoon tweet. ‘That’s the REAL reason for the ground stop…’”
Of course, this has nothing to do with “aliens.’ But something weird is going on. Note the next article.
And There Was More Chaos in America
Daily Mail wrote on November 16:
“United Airlines flights across the United States were grounded on Monday night… The airline announced on social media that it was experiencing a ‘widespread system outage’ as it apologized to customers ‘for the inconvenience.’… Earlier Monday, thousands of customers with Chase, Bank of America, Capital One and Wells Fargo also flagged being unable to log in or transfer money…
“A spokesperson for Chase told the Daily Mail the outage was caused by a technical bug… Wells Fargo also posted a note on its website telling customers that ‘online banking isn’t available right now’ due to ‘technical issues’.”
None of this is obviously mere coincidence.
The Daily Mail wrote on November 17:
“Markwayne Mullin suggested that artificial intelligence may have gone rogue and sparked the recent outages that caused chaos at airports and banks…
“Apple became the latest major company to be plunged into chaos on Tuesday as a wave of technology outages and cyberattacks rattled the US.”
CNN wrote on November 17:
“Highly classified US national security communications network goes down…”
Mere Coincidence???
Daily Mail wrote on November 17:
“Furious Republicans join panicking Americans demanding answers over wave of tech outages as they are brushed off as coincidence by Trump… Asked while in Manila, Philippines, whether he was concerned about the outages at Microsoft, United Airlines and Chase Bank, President Trump appeared to brush off the concerns. ‘It’s life. When you’re big and powerful and have all the money, things like that happen – it’s fine,’ he responded thousands of miles away…
“’If this is all a coincidence, it’s like the greatest coincidence in the history of the world,’ [Missouri Josh] Hawley told reporters at the Capitol on Tuesday. ‘You can’t tell me that all of this just is happenstance.’…
“Senator Rick Scott of Florida said Americans are increasingly frustrated by the wave of service outages and believe they are not being given the full picture, adding that even members of Congress have unanswered questions…”
Reuters wrote on November 17:
“Artificial intelligence is accelerating the pace and scale of cyberattacks, leading to more incidents reported by businesses and creating new challenges for companies and their insurers, data from insurance broker Marsh showed.”
AI To Kill Us in Six Months?
Daily Mail wrote on November 12:
“Paul Christiano, founder of the Alignment Research Centre, who warned there was a ‘high risk’ of an AI takeover within the next three years and even a ‘meaningful risk’ within six to 12 months. ‘I think… the most likely reason they will die is because of an AI accident’… Warning that society had failed to grasp the implications of super-intelligent machines, Professor Hinton added: ‘If it’s super-intelligent it’s not going to be you controlling it – it’s going to be it controlling you.’…
“He continued: ‘We’re now developing systems that will soon be much more intelligent than we are, and we have very little idea of how to ensure that they remain under our control.”
That is why the term “super intelligence” is so blasphemous and also so demonic. And our ignorant and naïve government seems to have no clue whom and what they are toying with.
Eric Trump’s Humanoid Robots
The Ron Paul Institute wrote on November 14:
“The Financial Times has published a new article titled ‘Humanoid robot start-up backed by Eric Trump in talks with Israel’s military,’ which is exactly as horrifying as its headline suggests. The article features photographs of bipedal armored robots which look like they came from the set of a post-apocalyptic Hollywood movie… The company has government contracts worth millions of dollars and high-profile backers to spread its message: Eric Trump, the president’s son, is both an investor and the company’s chief strategy adviser.
“I probably don’t need to explain to anyone reading this why it is insanely corrupt and dystopian for the president’s son to be making a fortune selling murderbot contracts to the US military while his warmongering father engages in reckless military expansionism around the world. But it really does highlight exactly where the US empire is at on the timeline of degradation and tyranny….
“I often see people wondering why AI is being shoved down our throats with little to no regulation despite the fact that it isn’t improving our lives in any meaningful way, but that’s because AI isn’t intended to benefit ordinary people. It’s intended to power autonomous military robots who will fire upon the citizenry if they attempt a revolution in ways human soldiers might refuse to do.”
They are playing with fire, apart from Eric Trump’s obvious blatant conflict of interest.
More Scientific Lunacy
The Spectator wrote on November 15:
“Palmer Luckey, one of Donald Trump’s favorite tech cowboys, founder of Anduril Industries which supplies drones to the US military, has just released details of Warhound, a joint venture with another tech cowboy, Ben Lamm of Colossal Biosciences [which] is famous for trying (and succeeding) to bring back extinct species using cloned and adapted DNA…. Anduril’s ‘EagleEye’ headpiece already allows human soldiers night vision, thermal vision, contact with drones and a constantly updating dynamic map of enemy terrain. The canine version of ‘EagleEye’ will be waiting for the pups when they’re trained… The first batch of pups is due next year, and soon after, if the dogs perform as expected, the great global hellhound-breeding arms race will begin….
“So just imagine, in the age of AI and gene editing, how competitive global Warhound breeding projects might end up. Colossal Biosciences is best known for its ‘de-extinction’ projects. They’ve claimed to have revived the vast extinct ‘dire wolf’ by reconstructing its genome and editing gray wolf cells to express key dire-wolf traits…. And what’s to stop Anduril adding armored, enhanced dire wolves to their military-kit stock list? Or saber-toothed tigers (we have the DNA)?”
The war industry loves it. Decent human beings should hate it.
Meet Former Catholic Sean Hannity
Daily Mail wrote on November 12:
“A-list actor John Cusack hit out at Sean Hannity this week after a left-leaning X account posted an old clip of the host renouncing his Catholic faith… At the time, Donald Trump and Pope Leo XIV were engaged in a bitter public row over the Iran war. ‘[A]s of today, I no longer consider myself a Catholic,’ Hannity, 64, says, in part, in the clip… The segment eventually saw Hannity accuse the Church of ‘totally los[ing] sight of the true meaning of the Bible and its teachings.’
“Cusack, 60, hit back… ‘[H]annity a bottomless pit of self loathing and one of the greatest grovelers to power in broadcast history’…
“[Hannity said:] ‘I went to Catholic school for 12 years. I even attended a seminary in high school, studied theology, Latin, went to Mass daily. I got a lot out of it. My parents, they were devout Catholics.’ He went on to explain why he was abandoning the religion, blaming not only the pope’s politics but ‘institutionalized corruption.’ ‘And it was at the parish level, to the bishop level, cardinals, all the way to Rome. And the very top scandals, terrible behavior, frankly went, not only unchecked, but they never fully corrected it, or dealt with it.’ Hannity added that ‘others at the Vatican [had] lost sight of the true meaning of the Bible and its teachings’…
“Producers propped up an Associated Press headline that credited the Holy Father with ‘amplif[ying] criticism’ of the conflict by branding all wars unforgivable. ‘Well, first, that is simply not biblically accurate,’ Hannity hit back, adding that the Bible ‘contains over 400 references to war… equally depicting God as authorizing, commanding, intervening in battles.’ He brought up ‘the one that we all know,’ between David and Goliath.”
Hannity would not have abandoned his Catholic faith if it had not been for the fight between the Pope and Hannity’s blind following of Donald Trump. What he says about corruption within the Catholic Church cannot be denied, but Hannity knew about that since childhood. What he says about war and the battles in the Bible only shows his complete ignorance of the biblical teaching. He should read our free booklet, “Should You Fight in War?”
Jeffrey Epstein Was Murdered!
Daily Mail wrote on November 16:
“Seven years after it was formally ruled that Jeffrey Epstein killed himself, a leading forensic scientist is challenging that official narrative. For years, questions have swirled, and conspiracies have abounded about the circumstances surrounding Epstein’s death. According to the New York City Office of Chief Medical Examiner, the FBI and the Department of Justice (DOJ), Epstein hanged himself in a federal jail cell in 2019 while awaiting trial on charges of sex trafficking minors. But Dr Michael Freeman, a forensic scientist with two doctorates in epidemiology and forensic medicine who spent a year examining Epstein’s autopsy file at the behest of the dead pedophile’s brother, has argued that Epstein did not, in fact, kill himself….
“It was [Jeffrey Epstein’s brother] Mark who gave Freeman access to Epstein’s autopsy file, which for years was kept away from third-party investigators and forensic scientists and pathologists. As Epstein’s next of kin, Mark was one of the only people to have access to the file. Mark gave the file to Freeman in November 2025, and since then, the forensic pathologist has studied it extensively…
“The two guards responsible for monitoring him, who had been assigned to his cell following an earlier alleged suicide attempt, reportedly fell asleep and failed to check on him for around three hours. At the same time, cameras outside his cell malfunctioned… After the body was found, evidence was sloppily catalogued, and the medical examiner was not allowed to inspect the cell… And although a noose was found in the cell, it was later discounted and didn’t match Epstein’s injuries…”
We are witnessing a massive cover-up by the New York City Office of Chief Medical Examiner, the FBI and the Department of Justice, leading to the obvious question as to who the high-profile villains are who are being protected, and on whose orders?
Putin the Victor
Bild Online wrote on November 18:
“The world is looking toward Shenzhen… Donald Trump (80), Chinese President Xi Jinping (73), and Vladimir Putin will sit across from one another at the negotiating table on the sidelines of the APEC (Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation) summit. This meeting—the most significant gathering of powerful figures in years—is set to address nuclear arms control, trade, AI, and the wars in the Middle East and Ukraine. One winner is already clear: Putin! For the despot, the meeting itself represents an enormous boost to his international standing. Following his 2022 invasion of Ukraine, he became a global pariah, barred from summits, while his country was hit with severe sanctions. Now, the warlord sits at the table with the leaders of the two superpowers to discuss the future of the world. After years of Western isolation, it is a diplomatic victory!
“It is Trump, above all, who has enabled the despot’s return to the high-stakes game of global power. He has facilitated the lifting of export bans and defends Putin at every turn—recently claiming, for instance, that Putin isn’t actually doing much in Ukraine… Ukrainian President Zelenskyy is forced to watch as negotiations take place over the heads of the Ukrainians and Europeans. He warns of a ‘new Yalta’—a reference to the historic 1945 summit that set the stage for the decades-long division of Europe. Kyiv’s greatest fear: that Trump might put territorial concessions on the table.”
Iran Not Defeated
The Jerusalem Post wrote on November 12:
“… the Islamic Republic of Iran ‘likely has at least 1,700 ballistic missiles remaining,’ and is building more every day… Iran has the capacity to build approximately 50 ballistic missiles per month…
“There could also be thousands of Shahed-type strike weapons remaining in its arsenal [unmanned drones that include ‘suicide’ variants that blur the line between traditional drones and cruise missiles.]”
Also, the existence of a new underground “missile city” site has been revealed.
Cuba Prepares for a US Attack
On November 14, ntv reported:
“According to leader Miguel Díaz-Canel, Cuba is preparing for a potential attack by the US military… In a radio interview, Trump signaled that he intends to force a change of power in Cuba during the remaining two-plus years of his term—and that he might even be prepared to use military force to achieve this. ‘I want Cuba taken care of before I leave,’ Trump said. He added that he would ‘certainly consider’ a military operation…
“Trump has commented on the possibility of a US military intervention in Cuba on several occasions. For instance, in October—ahead of the then-upcoming US congressional elections—he suggested that American warships, while returning from deployment in a war with Iran, could head toward the Caribbean island and station themselves off its coast; the leaders in Cuba, he claimed, would then surrender.”
Acknowledgement and Disclaimer:
These Current Events are compiled and commented on by Norbert Link. We gratefully acknowledge the many contributions of news articles from our readership. The publication of articles in this section is not to be viewed as an endorsement or approval as to the contents or accuracy of the selected articles, but they are published for the purpose of pointing to worldwide developments in the light of biblical end-time prophecy and godly instruction. Our own comments are provided in italics.
Q&A
The Future of France
France is in the news again; this time in reference to ongoing violent demonstrations in many cities. Last weekend, the fourth of those demonstrations in a row occurred. Officially described as protests by students, left-wing criminal elements infiltrated and hijacked the demonstrations and caused violence and destruction.
Whatever the actual causes were, the world was reminded of what France and the French people have become famous for: rebellion and revolution.
The Church of God has taught for a long time that the descendants of the biblical Reuben—the firstborn of Jacob—can be found in France. We will set forth additional biblical considerations for this conclusion below.
In his booklet, “The United States and Britain in Prophecy,” Herbert W. Armstrong wrote in the paperback version on page 144 (copyright 1980):
“The Tribe of Reuben settled in the country that is France today. They had lost their national identity. But the French have the very characteristics of their ancestor, Reuben. Today, through our free booklet in the French language revealing the ancestry and national identity, thousands of French people are beginning to learn their own identity.”
The booklet which Mr. Armstrong made reference to, was written by Dibar Apartian, “The French-Speaking Peoples In Prophecy,” copyright 1961. In chapter 12, he wrote:
“[The] Gauls are the descendants of the Reubenites who form, in essence, the French nation… The French are Israelites. The true ancestors are, before all, the Gauls, who were descendants of the Reubenites.”
We should mention, from the outset, that the identification of Reuben can also be deduced from reviewing the other continental European nations of Israelite origin. In our free booklet, Authority of the Bible, we say in chapter 12:
“Reuben [“Behold, a son!”] can be found today in parts of modern France; Dan [“judge”]in Ireland and part of Denmark; Benjamin [“son of my right hand”] in Norway and Iceland; Zebulon [“dwelling”] in the Netherlands; Issachar [“man of hire”] in Finland; Gad [“troop”] in Switzerland; Asher [“fortunate”] in Belgium and Luxembourg; and Naphtali [“my struggle”] in Sweden. We are unable to determine the modern identity of Levi and Simeon, as they were prophesied to be scattered among the rest of the tribes of Israel (compare Genesis 49:7)…
“We should mention, of course, that people from many other countries have joined with and settled among all of the above-mentioned nations.”
From the foregoing identification of the other Israelite nations in continental Europe, it follows that only Reuben could possibly be identified as France today.
As mentioned, the French people are historically known and stand out for rebellion and revolutions. Their ongoing and frequent “demonstrations” against the government and governmental agencies, leading often to violence, fit right in.
According to the Internet, we are told the following under “The Culture of Rebellion”:
“In France, protest is not seen as a breakdown of society, but as a fundamental democratic right and civic duty… The modern French identity was forged in the French Revolution of 1789, which overthrew the absolute monarchy and the Catholic Church’s absolute authority. This established a precedent: if the government fails the people, the people revolt… A pivotal modern moment where student-led protests and general strikes paralyzed the country. It completely reshaped French society, moving it away from conservative, traditional values toward a highly progressive, individualistic culture.”
In another article, it says:
“France is world-famous for its deep-rooted tradition of rebellion, protest, and revolution, viewing public action and street demonstrations as a core part of its political culture.”
It then lists numerous French revolutions and rebellions, including the most famous upheaval, The French Revolution (1789–1799),starting with the Storming of the Bastille on July 14, 1789, which overthrew the Ancien Régime, ended feudalism, and executed King Louis XVI. It was followed by a few lesser-known rebellions, such as the July Revolution (1830) and June Rebellion (1832),19th-century insurrections against restored monarchies (the latter famously immortalized in Victor Hugo’s Les Misérables); and the May 1968 massive student revolt coupled with a general worker strike that paralyzed the French economy and brought down the government of Charles de Gaulle.
Coupled with and almost inseparably intertwined with rebellion and revolution is the French perception of “sexual freedom”. The Internet states:
“The perception of French sexual freedom is less about hedonism and more about a distinct philosophical approach to privacy and pleasure… Thinkers like Voltaire and Rousseau, alongside writers like the Marquis de Sade, pushed boundaries by separating morality from religious dogma. The French championed the idea that what consenting adults do in private is nobody else’s business… France decriminalized homosexuality in 1791 during the Revolution—centuries before most other Western nations… In France, there is a strict cultural barrier between a person’s professional or public life and their private life. This is why political figures’ extramarital affairs or unconventional relationships rarely cause the career-ending scandals seen in Anglo-American politics; the public generally views it as irrelevant to their ability to govern… In summary, French rebellion secures political freedom, while their view on sexuality protects personal freedom. Both stem from a shared core value: a fierce resistance to having one’s life dictated by either the state or the church.”
A third characteristic of the French people in this context is that of chivalry, describing honorable conduct in the light of challenge or adversity. Pierre Terrail, Chevalier de Bahard (1473-1524), has been described as the ultimate French icon of honorable conduct, often protecting civilians and captured enemies alike. In addition, Geoffroi de Charny (1306-1356) was described by his contemporaries as a “true and perfect knight.” When he was captured by the English during the Hundred Years’ War, his reputation for honesty was so profound that his captors released him on his honor (parole) to raise his own ransom.”
Applying at least these three typical French characteristics to Reuben, we will see how they apply.
Jacob had twelve sons, but Joseph, one of the twelve, was envied and hated by his brothers. On one occasion, they conspired to kill him and cast him into some pit. When Reuben heard it, he objected and convinced them to cast him into a pit alive, planning to later deliver him out of the pit. While Reuben was gone, Judah proposed to sell Joseph to slave traders which they did. (Here, a special proclivity of the Jewish people is revealed—the love of money). When Reuben returned, he was very angry and grieved about the treacherous conduct of his brothers. At the least, Reuben showed some decency and chivalry or honorable conduct in trying to save Joseph, while his brothers showed absolutely none of it.
Previously, Reuben had exemplified another one of a French character trait… that of sexual “liberty,” coupled with rebellion against authority—that of his father. With his action, Reuben dishonored his father Jacob and rebelled against his authority (Deuteronomy 27:20; Leviticus 18:8).
In Genesis 35:22, we read: “And it happened, when Israel dwelt in that land, that Reuben went and lay with Bilhah his father’s concubine; and Israel heard about it. Now the sons of Jacob were twelve…”
As it had become public knowledge and was no longer a matter of “private sexual consent,” 1 Chronicles 5:1-2 informs us as to what happened next:
“Now the sons of Reuben the firstborn of Israel—he was indeed the firstborn, but because he defiled his father’s bed, his birthright was given to the sons of Joseph, the son of Israel, so that the genealogy is not listed according to the birthright; yet Judah prevailed over his brothers, and from him came a ruler, although the birthright was Joseph’s…”
We later read that Jacob adopted Joseph’s sons, Ephraim and Manasseh, and even though he passed the birthright to Joseph’s YOUNGER (!) son Ephraim, he made it clear to Joseph that Reuben and Simeon did not diminish in Jacob’s evaluation. We read in Genesis 48:5:
“And now your two sons, Ephraim and Manasseh, who were born to you in the land of Egypt before I came to you in Egypt, are mine; as Reuben and Simeon, they shall be mine.”
In Genesis 49:1-4, the evil sexual misconduct of Reuben is highlighted again. The passage reads in accordance with the New King James Bible:
“And Jacob called his sons and said, ‘Gather together, that I may tell you what shall befall you in the last days: Gather together and hear, you sons of Jacob, And listen to Israel your father. Reuben, you are my firstborn, My might and the beginning of my strength, The excellency of dignity and the excellency of power. Unstable as water, you shall not excel, Because you went up to your father’s bed; Then you defiled it—he went up to my couch.”
We should note, however, that verse 4 is often quite differently rendered in other translations:
The New International Version writes: “Turbulent as the waters, you will no longer excel, for you went up onto your father’s bed, onto my couch and defiled it.”
The New Living Translation translates verse 4: “But you are as unruly as a flood, and you will be first no longer. For you went to bed with my wife; you defiled my marriage couch.”
And the Good News Translation reads: “You are like a raging flood, But you will not be the most important, For you slept with my concubine And dishonored your father’s bed.”
Most German translations render it still quite differently:
The Lutherbibel 1984 translates verses 3-4 as follows:
“Reuben, you are my firstborn son, my strength and the first fruit of my vigor—foremost in rank and foremost in power. Because you were as turbulent as water, you shall not remain the first; for you climbed onto your father’s couch—there you defiled my bed when you ascended it. (“Ruben, mein erster Sohn bist du, meine Kraft und der Erstling meiner Stärke, der Oberste in der Würde und der Oberste in der Macht. Weil du aufwalltest wie Wasser, sollst du nicht der Oberste sein; denn du bist auf deines Vaters Lager gestiegen, daselbst hast du mein Bett entweiht, das du bestiegst.“)
The Einheistübersetzung states:
“Reuben, you are my firstborn, my strength, the first fruit of my virility, overflowing with pride, overflowing with power, surging like water. You shall not remain the first. For you climbed into your father’s bed; you defiled my couch when you did so.” (“Ruben, mein Erstgeborener bist du, meine Stärke, der Erste meiner Manneskraft, übermütig an Stolz, übermütig an Kraft, überschäumend wie Wasser. Der Erste sollst du nicht bleiben. Denn du hast das Bett deines Vaters bestiegen; du hast damals mein Lager entweiht.“)
The Zürcher Bibel writes:
“Reuben, you are my firstborn, my strength, the first fruit of my virility—foremost in rank and foremost in power. Unstable as water: you shall not remain the first, for you climbed into your father’s bed; you defiled my couch when you ascended it.” (“Ruben, mein Erstgeborener bist du, meine Stärke, der Erstling meiner Manneskraft, Erster an Hoheit und Erster an Macht. Überschäumend wie Wasser: Du sollst nicht der Erste bleiben, denn bestiegen hast du das Bett deines Vaters, damals hast du mein Lager entweiht, das du bestiegen hast.“).
And finally, The Hoffnung für Alle, translates verse 4:
“But you cannot restrain yourself—and that is why you will not remain the first. You have slept with one of my wives, thereby defiling your own father’s marriage bed.” (“Aber du kannst dich nicht im Zaum halten – darum wirst du nicht der Erste bleiben. Mit einer meiner Frauen hast du geschlafen und so das Ehebett deines eigenen Vaters entweiht.“).
In light of all those different renditions, the following comments are quite interesting:
The Study Bible writes:
“Reuben’s instability resembled turbulent waters that surge without restraint and cannot be relied upon… Jacob is highlighting Reuben’s impulsive nature; like water spilling over a riverbank, he lacked the restraint expected of the eldest son. The same imagery of instability appears later when James writes, ‘he who doubts is like a wave of the sea, blown and tossed by the wind’ (James 1:6), and Solomon notes, ‘Like a city whose walls are broken down is a man who lacks self-control’ (Proverbs 25:28).”
Matthew Poole’s Commentary adds:
“Unstable as water: this may concern… Reuben’s fault; and so he is said to have been unstable, or light, and vain, as the word is used; Judges 9:4; Zephaniah 3:4; like water, moved with every little wind of temptation, and unbounded in thy lust; as water of itself hath no bounds, but will scatter itself every way, if it be not kept within banks, or in a vessel: or, hasty, violent, impetuous in thy lust, like water, which either overflows or breaks its banks.”
These passages and the history discussed above describe the overall character of the French people—which of course does not mean that every French person can be characterized that way; especially, if the person is converted and overcoming his proclivities. But it is true that the Bible describes the character of certain people in very blunt ways (modern ignorant critics might call that hate speech). For instance, Paul says about the people of Crete that many of them are idle talkers and deceivers, whose mouth must be stopped (Titus 1:10-11). He even continues in verses 12-13, “Cretan are always liars… this testimony is true.” In Ezekiel 28:7, God says He will bring the Russians and the Ukrainians—“the most terrible of the nations”—against modern Germans and their allies. In Ezekiel 7:24, God calls the modern Germans and their allies “the worst of the Gentiles.”
The context shows that Jacob is talking about the status of Reuben within the tribes of Israel. Reuben would never again have the preeminence or the deep respect as the firstborn over the other tribes. This passage is foremost not addressing the status of Reuben in respect to the other Gentile nations of the world. It is not telling us that in the end times, Reuben will have no predominant or important role amongst the (Gentile) European nations. We have always spoken of the German-French engine that drives Europe; and that has been and will continue to be very true. At this point, France is the only nuclear power in continental Europe.
Notice the following end-time prophecy and blessing of Reuben in Deuteronomy 33:6:
“Let Reuben live, and not die, Nor let his men be few.”
Even though some commentaries, ignorant as to what God has pronounced, try to twist this passage, the meaning should be clear and obvious.
Yes, Reuben would still strive and prosper. But the French are turbulent and unruly like water, unstable, impulsive, unreliable and uncontrollable. As Reuben betrayed his father Jacob, so modern Reuben will betray the House of Israel. Even though being an Israelite nation, it will lock arms with many Gentile nations to attack and conquer the sons of Joseph—Ephraim and Manasseh —the United Kingdom and the USA.
Reuben will become sick and tired of their incompetent government (as will be the Germans, by the way), and so, the time will come when, perhaps under the influence of the “rebellious” and “impetus” French, ten European nations or groups of nations—undoubtedly under German, French and perhaps Italian leadership—will pass their authority to the “beast”—a charismatic military leader of German (Assyrian) descent. At that time, France will still have a mighty powerful military, which will be combined with the other militaries to create a unified European army. The United Kingdom will not be part of that constellation, but it will be considered an enemy of continental Europe (the old hostilities between France and Britain will come to light again).
Lead Writer: Norbert Link
The Work
Preaching the Gospel and Feeding the Flock
Compiled by Norbert Link
“Unexplained Outages and Unparalleled Chaos in America…” is the title of a new StandingWatch program, presented by Evangelist Norbert Link. Here is the summary:
Microsoft and bank outages; halting of all American flights; and even more chaotic conditions. But we are told by some that AI and cyberattacks have nothing to do with it. All of this is mere coincidence. But what is really going on?
“Unerklärte Ausfälle und beispielloses Chaos in Amerika…” is the title of a new AufPostenStehen program, presented by Norbert Link. This German program covers the same topics as described above.
All English and German messages from last Sabbath have been posted.
How This Work is Financed
This Update is an official publication by the ministry of the Church of the Eternal God in the United States of America; the Church of God, a Christian Fellowship in Canada; and the Global Church of God in the United Kingdom.
Editorial Team: Norbert Link, Rene Messier, Brian Gale, Johanna Link, Eric Rank, Michael Link, Anna Link, Kalon Mitchell, Manuela Mitchell, Dawn Thompson
Technical Team: Eric Rank, Shana Rank
Our activities and literature, including booklets, weekly updates, sermons on CD are provided free of charge. They are made possible by the tithes, offerings and contributions of Church members and others who have elected to support this Work.
While we do not solicit the general public for funds, contributions are gratefully welcomed and are tax-deductible in the U.S. and Canada.
Donations can be sent to the following addresses:
United States: Church of the Eternal God, P.O. Box 270519, San Diego, CA 92198
Canada: Church of God, ACF, Box 1480, Summerland, B.C. V0H 1Z0
United Kingdom: Global Church of God, PO Box 44, MABLETHORPE, LN12 9AN, United Kingdom
